Is the Steam Mop Better Than a Traditional Mop?

Steam mops and traditional mops both have their uses in our home-cleaning repertoire. Find out which one is best for you and why.

Are you wondering whether it’s worth investing in a steam mop? Should you just stick with a traditional mop instead and forego the hassle and cost?

Since there are so many mops to choose from nowadays, this is a popular debate. Both are going to clean the floors ­– but the question is, which one is best for your home?

Steam mops can sanitize your flooring, while traditional mops may be better for spills and quick accidents. Which product is going to come out on top? Let’s investigate and find out.

The Battle Commences

We’ve spent hours researching the advantages and disadvantages of these two cleaning devices. This includes analyzing customer feedback on different products and relating back to our own experiences. Let’s go over the pros and cons of each:

1. Steam Mop

The steam mop is easy to use — just swish it around the floor and you can get it spick and span. Steam mops boil water up to around 245 degrees Fahrenheit and then release water vapor onto a mop head.

They’re traditionally used by cleaning companies, especially for deep sanitization, like in healthcare facilities and hospitals. Recently, however, they’ve become a popular choice for single-family homes.

Why We Love It

Best for Tough Dirt and Mold

Steam mops excel when it comes to stubborn dirt. The water vapor may help to loosen grime for it to then be absorbed by the mop head. It can also tackle mold and since it has a fast drying time, it lowers the chance of further mold growth.

Some steam mops, such as the models from the Shark company, have different cleaning settings. This lets you customize the intensity for a quick or deep clean.

Safe for Kids and Pets

A busy family home calls for clean, safe flooring. The thing we love about a steam mop is that it only uses steam – no need for nasty, toxic chemicals. Your kids and pets will be able to walk on the floors afterward, without risking their health.

Kills Harmful Germs

Did you know that Salmonella can lurk around on your floors for up to four weeks (1)? If your family fancies a chicken dinner, this is worth noting. Thankfully, steam has natural sanitizing powers – good for allergies and keeping your family healthy.

Studies have found that steam possesses the ability to kill MRSA and VRE. Believe it or not, it takes just five seconds of contact (2). In the long run, that’s little effort to combat these potentially-harmful pathogens.

Less Scrubbing Effort

Forget manual scrubbing or hard labor – using a steam mop is quick and nearly effortless. It does require some prep work though.

All you’ve got to do is fill up the water tank and connect it to the power outlet. Some steam mops are cordless, which means they need a full charge.

The steam does all the hard work and you just have to glide around. You can even do it with one hand.

Keep In Mind

Requires Electricity or Batteries

Steam mops require electricity or batteries to emit consistent hot water vapor. If your mop requires a constant connection, that means you’ll always need to be near a power outlet. This may not be ideal if you’re working in a large space or trying to scrub outdoors.

A steam mop is normally simple to maneuver around objects – but the power cord may get stuck. It might get tangled around furniture or other items in the room you’re trying to clean. This can get old pretty fast.

On the other hand, if the mop requires a specific battery usage, that raises different issues. First, you’ll need to have those batteries on-hand. You’ll also have to make sure they’re fully charged before cleaning.

More Costly Than Traditional Mops

You may have a limited budget when it comes to cleaning accessories. We hate to break it to you, but steam mops can be a little pricey compared to traditional mops.

It’s going to come down to what you want to spend. Expect prices from around 50 dollars for the simple models up to around 150 dollars or more for higher-end and multi-functional options.

On the Heavier Side

Most steam mops are not lightweight, especially compared to traditional mops. You’re looking at around 6 to 10 pounds – before you fill up the water tank. This is compared to traditional mops at around 3 pounds.

If you have a large home, especially with more than one level, be prepared to put a little work into lugging it up and down stairs.

2. Traditional Mop

The mop and bucket – a cleaning classic. It’s now a lot more versatile than it once was, with lots of different shapes and sizes.

With no power cord or electricity needed, this one takes it back to the basics. You’ve got no user manual to read either. Simply fill the bucket up with your preferred cleaning solution and you’re good to go.

Why We Love It

Captures Dust and Bacteria

We favor microfiber mops over those with wool or cotton mop heads. Microfiber has the ability to reduce bacteria by 99 percent and has a static electric charge to capture dust (3).

The fibers work to trap any dirt present on your floor. A traditional mop may also be better than a steam mop for debris and crumbs.

Safe for Most Flooring

With a traditional mop, you’ve got the choice of a quick dry clean or a damp mop for a deep clean. This allows for versatile cleaning to suit your household schedule.

But it also allows you to use a traditional mop on any type of flooring with the exception of a carpet. A steam mop can’t be used on unsealed hardwood floors – yet a traditional mop can. You can dry mop the surface without any problems, picking up dirt on your way.

A traditional mop is safe to use on laminate, tiles, vinyl and pretty much any other surface when it’s dry.

Good for Quick Clean-Ups

A traditional mop with a microfiber pad will be quite absorbent. It can hold up to seven times its weight in water (4). This makes them good for cleaning up accidents after young kids or if you spill a drink.

Affordable Price

If money is an influencing factor in your purchasing decision, you may want to consider a traditional mop. They’re often affordable – definitely more budget-friendly than steam mops. The price will range from 16 to 45 dollars, depending on the brand.

Keep In Mind

Requires Some Physical Energy

Compared to steam mops, traditional mops do take more work. If you want to remove grime and stubborn dirt, you’ve got to put your back into it.

But this scrubbing may actually cause back pain. Often, this is because people bend the wrong way while they’re cleaning instead of staying upright (5).

You’ve also got to wring your mop when it gets too wet. While it doesn’t sound like a big deal, it’s still something you don’t have to do with a steam mop.

May Use Toxic Chemicals

It’s no secret that most cleaning solutions and detergents can be harmful to our health. This includes ingredients such as d-Limonene, pine oil parabens and 2-butoxyethanol (6).

The danger with a traditional mop is having to use toxic cleaning solutions to kill germs. Chemicals may not be safe for households with furry friends and young children.

You Might Also Like
Cleaning accessories (vacuum, mop and bucket, broom, etc.)10 Most Common Mopping Mistakes (Are You Making One?)

The Winner of the Mop Battle

Well, it’s ultimately going to be your decision whether you prefer a steam mop or a traditional mop.

If you’re looking for one that sanitizes your floors and is safe for kids and pets, consider the steam mop. It might be able to deal with stubborn dirt, mold, and stains too.

A traditional mop might be better for capturing dust and debris. Microfiber mop heads trap dirt and are suitable for all flooring. It’s also absorbent for spills. If budget is important to you, this is going to be the cheapest option.

Do you think there’s a clear winner between steam mops and traditional mops? Let us know down below in the comments!

Headshot of Amy Anthony

About the Author

Amy Anthony

Amy is a stay-at-home-mom, seasoned writer, and a home cleaning and organization aficionado. Amy enjoys having an absolutely spotless home and has worked hard to develop strategies to keep it that way, despite having 2 kids and 3 dogs!